Natalia Estemirova. Photo: REUTERS/Dylan Martinez (BRITAIN)

01 September 2021, 11:23

Moscow: debaters disappointed by ECtHR's decision on Estemirova's murder case

The European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) has failed to find Russia responsible for the death of Natalia Estemirova due to political reasons, human rights defenders assert.

The "Caucasian Knot" has reported that on August 31, the ECtHR, while recognizing the absence of an efficient inquiry into Natalia Estemirova's murder, awarded compensation to her sister for moral harm in the amount of 20,000 euros. Human rights defenders have expressed regret that the ECtHR failed to treat Russia as responsible for Estemirova's death.

On August 31, in Moscow, the editorial office of the "Dozhd" (Rain) TV Company** hosted a roundtable dedicated to the ECtHR's decision on the murder of Natalia Estemirova. Oleg Orlov, a board member of the Human Rights Centre (HRC) "Memorial"*, and Elena Milashina, a columnist for the "Novaya Gazeta", were invited to speak on air; Tatiana Glushkova, a lawyer of the HRC "Memorial"*, and Lana, the Estemirova's daughter, also spoke via a video link.

Tatiana Glushkova has welcomed the ECtHR's ruling "with an offense, seeing violations." "The decision has upset and shocked ... The ECtHR has failed to analyze in any way that Natalia received threats. The ECtHR has also ignored the information about kidnapping people in Chechnya," Ms Glushkova has stated.

According to Elena Milashina, a journalist, the ECtHR's decision is also dangerous. "The ECtHR has given a naive argument that it failed to find state agents guilty of the murder, pointing out that it is not clear whether these people were militaries, law enforcers or not; it asked a question: maybe they were militants? In this case, what prevents the state to hire drunken guys to beat Orlov and me up? The Investigating Committee will not investigate," Ms Milashina said.

The reason why the ECtHR is "extremely cautious, fearful and even cowardly" about claims from Russia lies in the fact that the Russian Federation "resorts to pressure and blackmail in the Council of Europe," while "no one wants to exclude Russia from there," Oleg Orlov told the "Caucasian Knot" correspondent after the broadcast.

The case has political weight; and the greater it is, the more "concrete evidence is needed for the ECtHR to find the state guilty," Ms Glushkova told the "Caucasian Knot" correspondent.

*The organization has been included by the Russian Ministry of Justice into the register of the non-commercial organizations (NCOs) performing the functions of a foreign agent.

**The edition has been included by the Russian Ministry of Justice into the register of the mass media performing the functions of foreign agents.

This article was originally published on the Russian page of 24/7 Internet agency ‘Caucasian Knot’ on September 1, 2021 at 01:41 am MSK. To access the full text of the article, click here.

Author: Oleg Krasnov Source: CK correspondent

Комментирование через Кавказский узел
All news
НАСТОЯЩИЙ МАТЕРИАЛ (ИНФОРМАЦИЯ) ПРОИЗВЕДЕН И РАСПРОСТРАНЕН ИНОСТРАННЫМ АГЕНТОМ ООО “МЕМО”, ЛИБО КАСАЕТСЯ ДЕЯТЕЛЬНОСТИ ИНОСТРАННОГО АГЕНТА ООО “МЕМО”.

April 03, 2025 22:57

  • Relatives of political prisoners announce 24-hour protest in Tbilisi

    Families of oppositionists arrested in connection with participation in pro-European protest actions have united in a public movement to demand the release of prisoners of conscience. The activists plan to start a 24-hour protest action in front of the parliament building in Tbilisi.

April 03, 2025 22:13

  • Sister of convicted Rizvanov demands answer about legality of law enforcers’ visits

    Two men came to the house of the parents of Abubakar Rizvanov, who was sentenced to imprisonment in a case on terrorism financing, and demanded the information about the place of residence of his children. A sister of Abubakar Rizvanov regarded the constant visits by law enforcers as pressure and demanded an answer about the legality of their actions.

April 03, 2025 21:58

April 02, 2025 22:55

  • Verdict to Sochi resident Schus upheld

    The appellate court has refused to change the sentence passed to Alexei Schus, a Sochi engineer, convicted on charges of spreading fake news about the Russian Army and making a slingshot.

April 02, 2025 21:15

  • Kurban Dalgatov's mother assess trial prospects of her son's death case

    The law enforcers guilty of the death of Kurban Dalgatov, a Makhachkala resident, are trying in every way to avoid punishment, while the judges are following their lead, the mother of Kurban, who died after being tortured by the police. The trial of Dalgatov's death case will continue on April 30 this year.

News archive
Пн
Вт
Ср
Чт
Пт
Сб
Вс
31
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
1
2
3
4